Alaska Goes Blue: Sullivan Loses Seat... And 'Decoy Dan' Had Nothing To Do With It

Alaska Goes Blue: Sullivan Loses Seat... And 'Decoy Dan' Had Nothing To Do With It

Alaska Goes Blue: Sullivan Loses Seat... And 'Decoy Dan' Had Nothing To Do With It

Democrat Mary Peltola has unseated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, winning an outright majority of first-choice votes and sparing the state the ranked-choice count in which Republicans had hoped to win back votes cast for the second "Dan Sullivan" on the ballot. NBC News projected her the winner at 10:19 p.m. ET on Tuesday, and the Associated Press called it the same night.

The Alaska Division of Elections' Tuesday evening count, with all 401 precincts reporting and 290,003 ballots cast, has Peltola at 144,302 votes, or 50.12%, to Sullivan's 131,844, or 45.80%: a lead of 12,458. Republican Gerald Heikes has 6,105 and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., the retired Petersburg teacher Republicans call "Decoy Dan," has 4,760, with 885 write-ins.

"They put in two fake candidates, not one. And if you add them up, Dan Sullivan wins," President Trump told reporters on Monday, calling what happened in Alaska "absolutely a disgrace."

Hand the senator every vote cast for the other Sullivan, every vote for Heikes and every write-in, and he would still finish 708 votes behind Peltola. Because she cleared 50% on the first count, no ballot is ever redistributed, so voters who ranked "Decoy Dan" first never get a second choice counted at all.

Trump had demanded that the state move the second Sullivan's votes to the "REAL Dan Sullivan," and her lead passed that pile of votes on Nov. 10. By Monday it sat 52 votes short of a majority, with the last ballots still to come in.

The seat is the ninth Democrats flipped in the midterms, the most since 1958, according to the AP, and turns a 53-47 Republican Senate into a 56-44 Democratic one, counting independents Angus King and Bernie Sanders.

All but one of the nine are in states Trump carried in 2024, according to NBC, and he carried Alaska in 2016 and 2020 as well. Alaska was the last Senate race to be decided.

Peltola, who held Alaska's lone House seat from 2022 until she lost it to Republican Nick Begich in 2024, will be the first Alaska Native to serve in the Senate and the state's first Democratic senator since Mark Begich, whom Sullivan beat in 2014. Alaskans sent a message that "the status quo in D.C. is not working for Alaska," she said in a statement. She outraised Sullivan $37 million to $14 million through mid-October, according to NBC.

Sullivan's campaign, which has not conceded, said on Monday it would let the process "run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified," and after the call spokesman Nate Adams said only that "the campaign will have more to say by the end of this week." The state finishes counting on Wednesday, the deadline for overseas ballots, and plans to certify on Nov. 25. Peltola takes the seat when the new Congress convenes in January.

The fight over the second Sullivan isn't over with the count. After the New York Times reported in October that Peltola's campaign and national Democrats helped get him on the ballot, Trump called for her prosecution and ordered a Justice Department lawsuit to block certification if the senator lost. A federal judge threw the suit out, and the Justice Department has appealed to the Ninth Circuit. The department has also confirmed a criminal investigation, which reportedly reaches Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias, as we reported. Peltola denies any role in recruiting him, and he has denied any contact with her campaign. "I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent," she has said.

Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins also won the governor's race with 51.07% of the vote, the first Democrat to win it since 1998. The state's House seat is still open: Begich leads independent Bill Hill 47.54% to 41.77%, short of a majority, so that race goes to a ranked-choice count.

Tyler Durden